top of page
RECTOR SEARCH

Welcome to the St. James Rector Search. As we embark on this sacred pilgrimage to find our next spiritual leader, we invite you to explore our Parish Profile. Located in the heart of Midvale, Utah, St. James is a vibrant, inclusive community dedicated to "Celebrating God’s Love and Sharing it with All."  

We are a parish that values intellectual freedom, liturgical beauty, and active service—from our bustling food bank to our beloved camping ministry. We seek a shepherd to join us in our mission of radical hospitality and spiritual growth. Explore our story below and discern if God is calling you to lead our faithful community.​​​

If you are someone who will walk alongside us on our journey forward...

If you’re a dynamic leader who can help us achieve our vision and build on our strengths...

And if you are eager to help us build lay leadership capacity, strengthen our community connections, and collaborate with us to solve our challenges we invite you to submit your curriculum vitae, VocationHub Questionnaire, and cover letter to:

 

The Rev. Canon Jeff Stevenson
Canon to the Ordinary and Transition Minister
Episcopal Diocese of Utah

jstevenson@episcopal-ut.org
mhanners@episcopal-ut.org
801.322.4131

NEWS

5.12.2026

PARISH PROFILE SUBMITTED TO BISHOP AND TRANSITION MINISTER!

Today is a momentous step in our Rector Search Process!    Search Committee Chair, Kari Butler, officially submitted the final draft of our Parish Profile to Rt. Rev. Bishop Phyllis and Transition Minister, Canon to the Ordinary Jeff Stevenson.   

It is with immense gratitude that everyone that had input to the profile.   Hundreds of hours have been put into the final product.   We especially want to thank Kim Smart, Search Committee Member, who took leadership for the product, brought her expert creativity and writing skills to the table, learned several new tools and coordinated with dozens of contributors throughout the congregation to build a document truly representative of our congregation.  

5.1.2026

SAYING THANKS WITH ICE CREAM
SEARCH COMMITTEE TO CHEER PARISHIONERS FOR THEIR SUPPORT

The people of St. James really are incredible and are making the work of the Rector Search Committee so much more effective, the committee’s chair reported. “Now we are working on a special way to say thank you,” said Kari Butler. “This is because we are about to complete a major milestone and the enthusiastic participation of so many parishioners is making it possible.”
 
“One of the primary products necessary to complete an effective rector search is the production of a truly reflective parish profile,” she explained. “And to be an absolutely accurate picture of what likely will be a rector candidate’s first impression of St. James we needed to hear from everyone.”
 
“And we did,” she added. “So, get ready for ‘Sundaes on Sunday!’”
 
In both the parish survey and the follow-up focus groups there was a very healthy participation rate. The information parishioners provided will find its way into the parish profile, which is a comprehensive documentation of St. James. It describes who we are as a parish, the priorities of the congregation in terms of worship, pastoral care, its place in the community, and its educational and social priorities, as well as its hopes and dreams for the future. It often is the primary source of information about the parish for rector candidates.
 
“So you can see it’s vitally important to get it right,” Kari explained, “and the only way to ensure its accuracy is to hear from as many parishioners as possible.” The St. James community answered the call in fine fashion.
Therefore, you cordially are invited to “Sundaes on Sunday” after each of the services on May 24 for an ice cream-infused social hour hosted by your Rector Search Committee. “It’s our way of saying thank you,” said Kari.
 
Just how well did St. James do? Well, a survey response rate of 80 percent of Average Sunday Attendance (ASA) is considered a valid reflection of a parish. St. James had a response rate of 96 percent. “That’s incredible,” said Kari. So were the results. The overall theme can be characterized as St. James is “a really good place to be,” reported the survey facilitator from Holy Cow, a firm the parish engaged to create the survey and interpret the results. “There is a very high level of satisfaction,” she added. This is important, she explained, because it means we don’t have to find a rector “to fix anything.” The results also revealed St. James possesses an adaptable and progressive culture but one that could deepen its pastoral care efforts.
 
Generally speaking, the parish placed prime importance on three priestly characteristics for a new rector. These points of emphasis are preaching, pastoral care and strategic leadership. A good fit for someone to join the parishioners at St. James is someone who is “theologically progressive but open to other ideas (and) dynamic enough to connect through worship,” said the Holy Cow representative. The data also revealed St. James wants someone with networking talents and an ability to form community connections. “We can put these parish priorities front and center in our search,” Kari said, “because everyone in the parish participated in the survey.”
 
The survey provided many “what” answers relative to what the parish wants in a rector. The follow-up focus groups were designed to determine the “why” the responses were what they were. Once again, the parish stepped up and four focus group sessions were scheduled. Due to the privacy promised to promote the most heartfelt and unedited responses, it’s possible only to comment in a general sense relative to the information gathered in the groups.
 
However, the committee can report that the focus groups confirmed the survey results. Dynamic preaching, a greater emphasis on pastoral care and attracting more young families all prominently were mentioned. Equally important were the comments universally held by participants that St. James is a very welcoming place. This quality must be continued and expanded agreed all, particularly if we’re to attract and maintain more young families.
 
A tremendous amount of thanks and appreciation is due Toni Sutliff for bringing her professional excellence and expertise to her role of focus group facilitator. She raced to St. James on three different Sundays from her home parish - All Saints - to conduct the focus groups - and waived off any remuneration for her services. Her efforts were a real gift to the parish. Members of the committee were gratified to receive a great many comments from parishioners regarding how much they enjoyed the focus groups and how valuable they believed they were. “People felt heard,” said Kari, “and that is so important, not only in the search for a new rector but for the future of the parish generally.”
 
“It was an hour very well spent,” said parishioner Barry Wirth at a recent session of the Grumpies.

1.12.2026

CHURCH ASSESSMENT SURVEY AVAILABLE NOW THROUGH 2/9/26

The link to participate in the congregational survey is in your email inboxes now.   It was sent at 7:00am on 1/12/26. This on-line instrument /survey will help the leadership of our congregation gauge the strength, vitality, and trends in our church.  The information gained from this assessment will be valuable in helping the leaders of St. James as we make decisions about our future.

Surveys need to be completed by February 9th, 2026.  

If you have questions, please contact Kari Butler at searchchair@stjamesutah.com.

11.9.2025

KARI BUTLER SPEAKING IN WORSHIP, SEARCH COMMITTEE BLESSED

During the Ministry Moment in both services on November 9th, Kari Butler talked about our journey, where we are headed and introduced the Search Committee.   Listen to her message by pressing play below.   ​​

Kari Butler Ministry Moment - 11.9
00:00 / 04:14
Search Committee Blessing.jpeg

Search Committee Blessing - (L to R) - Steve Hutchinson, Steve Allnatt, Britley Randstatler, Mindy Mitchell, Rev. Terry Heyduk, Laura Orcutt, Kari Butler, Kim Smart with alternates Susan Furca and Mark Rigtrup.

11.4.2025

RECTOR SEARCH COMMITTEE FORMED!

Dear People of St. James - 


I am pleased to announce that the Rector Search Committee has been formed! The candidates were reviewed with the Vestry and the Vestry voted unanimously to affirm the members of the committee.

 

The Rector Search Committee is led by chair, Kari Butler, and includes members:

Steve Allnatt

Steve Hutchinson

Mindy Mitchell

Laura Orcutt

Britley Randstatler

Kim Smart

 

The meetings of the search committee will commence soon and we will begin sharing out our progress and how you can support our Rector search process.  We will continue to have updates in our weekly newsletter, Koinonia, and here on this page.


With Gratitude,
Kari Butler

Search Committee Chair

10.16.2025

LAST CALL FOR SEARCH COMMITTEE APPLICATIONS

It is our hope that you have each prayerfully considered the calling to create the Rector Search Committee. 
 

Applications are DUE TOMORROW, 10/17/2025.   To apply click on the button below to fill out the electronic form.   If you require a paper application you can download it here. 

 

If you have questions or want to discuss the Rector Search Committee role with us, please don't hesitate to email or call. 

With Gratitude,

Kari Butler

Search Committee Chair

David James

Senior Warden

10.7.2025

Search Committee Application Form Available

The application to submit your interest in being on the Search Committee is available.

Interested members of the congregation need to submit their form by October 17, 2025.

The Search Committee, under the direction of the Vestry and Committee Chair Kari Butler, is responsible from beginning to end for the Rector Search process. The time commitment is 2-4 hours per week for 12 to 18 months. Some time periods will have heavier hours during critical times. The Search Committee has a wide variety of tasks, including parish surveys, preparing and evaluating data, preparing the parish profile, preparing for and performing rector candidate interviews, and speaking with members throughout the congregation. Skills desired are in project management, communication, writing and technology, and assessment and evaluation.

To apply click on the button below to fill out the electronic form.   If you require a paper application you can download it here. 

Questions about the Rector Search Process can be directed to our Search Committee Chair, Kari Butler, at searchchair@stjamesutah.com.

9.23.2025

Rector Search Committee Chair Announced

At a special meeting of the Vestry on the evening of September 23, 2025, David James, Senior Warden, announced the appointment of Kari Butler as Chair of the Rector Search Committee being formed to identify candidates to fill the Rector vacancy.  

 

The primary goals for the meeting were to introduce Kari to the Vestry and review the Diocesan Policy and Procedure on Calling a Priest.   
 

During this meeting Kari introduced herself and shared her experience that uniquely qualifies her for this role.   Beyond Kari's extensive leadership background in corporate America, specifically in television broadcasting, she has experience within The Episcopal Church including acting as the Chair of the Transition Committee for Bishop Scott Hayashi.  She explained that our Rector Search Committee would work a lot like the Transition Committee and was excited to impart her learnings at St. James.  She has also served on Diocesan Council and the Diocesan Standing Committee.

 

Kari and her husband Cliff began attending  St. James in 1993 at the church previous to our current location.  They raised their children at St. James and at St. James she has held many leadership roles including Senior Warden, Junior Warden, and Sunday School Teacher.  

Kari will immediately begin working with Vestry Members Greg Annis and Terry Palmer to create the Search Committee Application that will be shared with members of the congregation to express their interest in being on the Search Committee.   The goal is to have a Search Committee of seven members in place by October 31, 2025.  

Questions about the Rector Search can be directed to Kari by email.  

Kari Butler.jpg

Rector Search Committee

St. James Episcopal Church, Midvale, Utah, occupies and operates upon the ancestral and traditional lands of the Northwestern Shoshone, Goshute, and Ute Tribes.

©2026 by St. James Episcopal Church

bottom of page